Wednesday, April 16, 2014

A New Idea: Poverty Porn

My family and I are crazy about Planet Earth. I could probably watch it all day. Seeing our beautiful world so incredibly documented makes the wheels in my brain start spinning out trips I want to take, stories I want to tell, sites I want to see, smells I want to breathe. My brain engine is greased and ready, revving, eager to embark on some new journey, and then I remember I’m sitting on the couch with my sisters in our house in Ohio. We’re somewhere in the world, and it’s beautiful, but it’s not like the elephant herd creating a cloud of dust as they storm across the African plain, or the cave with a 300 ft. tall pile of bat droppings millions of bats call their home, or the great barrier reef in Australia, or the artic fox hunting geese in the tundra. Watching from our plush seats as the smell of mom’s homemade artisan bread makes it’s way into the room makes what’s on the screen feel so distant...yet so close. Because at that moment, I do know the world is rotating, tides are sweeping in and out, and some man is floating down the amazon on his hollowed-tree boat, fishing in electric eel infested waters. We’re all doing life somewhere.

I always knew these things and imagined how life moves in another continent and culture. The foreign unknown is nearly always on my mind. However, there is something so shaking about exposure to a place you’ve only dreamed of traveling to. Suddenly you’re not just sitting on your nice comfortable couch staring wide eyed at a screen depicting only a sliver of what a place is like, you’re walking on the ground of a new-to-you country and seeing strange birds’ nests in the trees, smelling the air at sunset you can’t even recognize, freaking out as you make your way through an intersection on the opposite side of the road than you’re used to, hearing many languages (you don’t know how many, you just know you can’t understand), and learning when someone looks at you and says, “you’re big”, not to take it offensively.

Even Planet Earth can’t prepare you for this kind of experience.

When we went to Winterton in March, a culmination of wonder, excitement, and heartache hit me. The best pictures and videos don’t ease the eye opening impact received when you see life in rural mountain villages. It can’t prepare you to see a 3 year old walking down the highway without shoes, or when you realize you have more just in your bedroom than these people probably have in their entire house.

I’m not trying to take you on a guilt trip or make you wallow in forced sympathy or incite self-deprivation. I am broaching the idea of poverty porn. The concept that we are fascinated to see poverty in magazines and advertisements, intrigued that “wow, that person only makes $1 per day”, and ogling that a woman has to carry water 5 miles home on her head every day. Gawking, not giving. Concerned, not convicted. Interested, not impacted. Sympathetic, not empathetic. We’ve been so bombarded we’ve become desensitized.

This isn’t love. Love is seeing a photo of an impoverished region and praying for the people. Love is keeping granola bars in your glove box to hand to the man who always sits on the corner trying to sell newspapers. Love is building relationships and pouring yourself out onto lonely, desperate people who need love, too. It’s aching for that face in the picture, not dismissing it as if the person is only imaginary. Love is grasping that this is actually real life for people.


Let me change my egotism to compassion. Let me learn from where I have been.


Don and Cheryl Allen who began Door of Hope also started the ministry Arise, which built this nursery school. 105 children from the nearby area were there when we came. They are served a meal and taught during the day to prepare them for primary school. They jabbered and clicked away in Zulu and I couldn’t talk back, but we all knew the language of love. They were delightful, little models in front of the camera, and stared in wonder as I showed them videos of themselves. We were friends when they left and I am so fortunate to have met and been so impacted by their young lives.

(school can wear you out)





Pastor M, who generously welcomed us and fed us lunch, with his daughter.